CHAPTER 4
False Asceticism.*
* [4:1–5] Doctrinal deviations from the true Christian message within the church have been prophesied, though the origin of the prophecy is not specified (1 Tm 4:1–2); cf. Acts 20:29–30. The letter warns against a false asceticism that prohibits marriage and regards certain foods as forbidden, though they are part of God’s good creation (1 Tm 4:3).
* [4:5] The invocation of God in prayer: literally, “the word of God and petition.” The use of “word of God” without an article in Greek suggests that it refers to the name of God being invoked in blessing rather than to the “word of God” proclaimed to the community.
* [4:6–10] Timothy is urged to be faithful, both in his teaching and in his own life, as he looks only to God for salvation.
* [4:10] Struggle: other manuscripts and patristic witnesses read “suffer reproach.”
* [4:11–16] Timothy is urged to preach and teach with confidence, relying on the gifts and the mission that God has bestowed on him.
* [4:12] Youth: some commentators find this reference a sign of pseudepigraphy. Timothy had joined Paul as a missionary already in A.D. 49, some fifteen years before the earliest supposed date of composition.
* [4:13] Reading: the Greek word refers to private or public reading. Here, it probably designates the public reading of scripture in the Christian assembly.
* [4:14] Prophetic word: this may mean the utterance of a Christian prophet designating the candidate or a prayer of blessing accompanying the rite. Imposition of hands: this gesture was used in the Old Testament to signify the transmission of authority from Moses to Joshua (Nm 27:18–23; Dt 34:9). The early Christian community used it as a symbol of installation into an office: the Seven (Acts 6:6) and Paul and Barnabas (Acts 13:3). Of the presbyterate: this would mean that each member of the college of presbyters imposed hands and appears to contradict 2 Tm 1:6, in which Paul says that he imposed hands on Timothy. This latter text, however, does not exclude participation by others in the rite. Some prefer to translate “for the presbyterate,” and thus understand it to designate the office into which Timothy was installed rather than the agents who installed him.
a. [4:1] 2 Tm 3:1; 4:3; 2 Pt 3:3; Jude 18.
b. [4:3] Gn 9:3; Rom 14:6; 1 Cor 10:30–31.
c. [4:4] Gn 1:31; Acts 10:15.
d. [4:7] 1:4; 2 Tm 2:16; Ti 1:14.
f. [4:9] 1:15; 2 Tm 2:11; Ti 3:8.
h. [4:12] 1 Cor 16:11; Ti 2:15 / Phil 3:17.
i. [4:14] 5:22; Acts 6:6; 8:17; 2 Tm 1:6.
IV. Duties toward Others
Copyright 2019-2025 USCCB, please review our Privacy Policy